THE PERSONAL BREW BENCH

Café de Olla Recipe by Rick Bayless and Pati Jinich

How the café de olla recipes from Rick Bayless and Pati Jinich use piloncillo, cinnamon and clay-pot brewing, and how to adapt either one at home.

2 min read5 viewsCafé de Olla Recipe by Rick Bayless and Pati Jinich
— · 0 votes
Contents
  1. What the two chef recipes share
  2. How to compare the two versions
  3. Adjusting either recipe at home
  4. Questions about chef café de olla recipes
  5. What is in Pati Jinich's café de olla recipe?
  6. How does Rick Bayless make café de olla?
  7. Can I use brown sugar instead of piloncillo?
  8. What kind of cinnamon works in café de olla?

Rick Bayless and Pati Jinich both make café de olla by simmering piloncillo and cinnamon before adding coffee. Both chefs are known for Mexican cooking, and their versions stay close to the home-style drink. The differences sit in the details, such as sweetness, extra spices, grind and steep time. Their published recipes hold the exact amounts, and this page explains how to read and adjust them.

What the two chef recipes share

The café de olla recipes from Bayless and Jinich both rest on piloncillo, a hard unrefined cane sugar. Piloncillo melts into hot water and adds a molasses-like, slightly smoky sweetness. A whole cinnamon stick simmers alongside it to scent the water before any coffee goes in. Ground coffee then steeps in the sweet, spiced water and is strained before serving.

How to compare the two versions

A fair comparison of the Bayless and Jinich café de olla recipes changes only the recipe itself. Brew each version in the same pot, with the same beans and the same grind size. Write down the piloncillo amount, the spices and the steep time for each cup. Taste for sweetness, spice strength and bitterness, then note which balance suits your morning ritual.

Adjusting either recipe at home

Either chef's café de olla brews well in a saucepan or a clay pot called an olla. Grate or chop the piloncillo so it dissolves evenly before the coffee goes in. Keep the heat gentle once the grounds are added, because hard boiling pulls out bitterness. If you use a glazed clay pot, choose one sold as lead-free for cooking.

Questions about chef café de olla recipes

What is in Pati Jinich's café de olla recipe?

Pati Jinich's café de olla uses the classic base of piloncillo, cinnamon, water and ground coffee. Check her published recipe for the exact quantities and any extra flavorings in her version. Follow those amounts once as written before you change sweetness or strength.

How does Rick Bayless make café de olla?

Rick Bayless makes café de olla by sweetening and spicing water before steeping the coffee in it. Piloncillo and cinnamon go in first so their flavor fills the water. The coffee steeps in that liquid and is strained, which keeps the cup clear rather than gritty. His printed recipe gives the precise ratio of coffee, sugar and water to follow.

Can I use brown sugar instead of piloncillo?

Yes, dark brown sugar can stand in for piloncillo in either chef's café de olla. Brown sugar tastes lighter and less smoky, and the cup loses some depth. A small amount of molasses brings the flavor closer to the original.

What kind of cinnamon works in café de olla?

Ceylon cinnamon, known as canela in Mexico, is the traditional choice for café de olla. Canela is soft and flaky, with a mild, floral flavor that melts into the coffee. Cassia cinnamon works too but tastes hotter and sharper. A smaller piece of cassia keeps the spice in balance.

Read next

Latest articles