THE PERSONAL BREW BENCH

Calculate coffee TDS and extraction yield and read the SCAA drip-brewing chart

How TDS, beverage-based extraction yield, brew ratio and taste differ, how to calculate extraction from refractometer readings, and how to read the 2016 SCAA drip-brewing chart.

6 min readThe ratio desk9 viewsCalculate coffee TDS and extraction yield and read the SCAA drip-brewing chart
— · 0 votes
Contents
  1. The short answer
  2. Four terms that get mixed up
  3. Worked examples of beverage-based extraction
  4. Getting a usable TDS reading
  5. Reading the SCAA drip-brewing chart
  6. When the brew is diluted with bypass water
  7. A brew journal layout that keeps the numbers honest

The short answer

TDS (total dissolved solids) is how concentrated your coffee is. It is the percentage of the drink, by mass, that is dissolved coffee. Extraction yield (EY) is how much of your dry coffee dose ended up dissolved in the drink. You do not calculate TDS yourself. A refractometer measures the liquid's refractive index and converts it to TDS%. You then calculate beverage-based extraction yield from that reading.

Dissolved coffee (g) = beverage mass (g) × TDS% ÷ 100
Extraction yield (%) = 100 × dissolved coffee (g) ÷ dry dose (g)

Shortcut: EY% = beverage mass × TDS% ÷ dry dose

The SCAA drip-brewing chart plots strength (TDS) against extraction. Its diagonal lines, however, are drawn from the ratio of coffee to input water, not from the weight of the brew you collected. Keep four things in separate places: concentration, beverage-based extraction, input ratio and how the cup tasted.

Four terms that get mixed up

TermWhat it describesHow you get it
TDS / strength / solubles concentrationPercentage of the liquid that is dissolved coffeeMeasured with a refractometer on a sample of a specific liquid
Extraction yield / solubles yieldPercentage of the dry dose that dissolved into the drinkCalculated from TDS, beverage mass and dry dose
Input ratioWater poured in relative to dry coffee, e.g. 14:1, or grams of coffee per liter of waterWeighed before brewing
Sensory observationSweetness, bitterness, body, clarity, and so onTasting notes; never a substitute for a measured number

Input water and collected beverage are different numbers because the grounds hold back some water. Beverage-based extraction uses the weight of the liquid you actually collected. If you put input water into that formula instead, the result will be wrong.

Worked examples of beverage-based extraction

Example published by coffee writer Mikami: a 10 g dose brewed with 140 g of water gives an input ratio of 14. That brew yielded 121 g of beverage at 1.6% TDS. Extraction yield = 121 × 1.6 ÷ 10 = 19.36%. TDS is entered as the percentage number (1.6), not as 0.016. If you use the decimal form, multiply by 100 at the end.

Illustrative example, constructed for this guide: assume a baseline-corrected reading of 1.20% TDS, 270 g of collected beverage and an 18 g dose. Dissolved coffee = 270 × 0.012 = 3.24 g. Extraction yield = 100 × 3.24 ÷ 18 = 18%. This calculation covers only the collected beverage. Do not quietly reuse it as a total-extraction figure for an immersion brew.

Mikami has also described serving coffee at around 14% EY and under 1.2% TDS. That is one person's attributed preference, not a target everyone should aim for. It shows why the numbers describe a cup without ruling on whether you will like it.

Getting a usable TDS reading

The extraction figure can only be as good as the TDS reading. The guidance for the DiFluid R2 Extract (model DFT-R102) outlines this routine:

  • Start with a clean sample dish.
  • Zero the device with room-temperature pure water. Wait about five seconds, then give a short press followed by a held press until the display shows Zeroing.
  • Dry the dish, add cooled coffee, and tap to measure.
  • Leave at least three seconds between consecutive tests.
  • Use the device within its stated operating range of 5–40°C, and keep the sample and the device at matching temperatures.

DiFluid describes two zeroing choices. You can zero with your brewing water, or with distilled water. If you zero with distilled water, measure your brewing water separately and subtract that baseline before you calculate extraction. Otherwise the minerals in your water get counted as coffee.

Reading the SCAA drip-brewing chart

The chart discussed here comes from the SCAA Technical Standards Committee's Guidelines for Using By-Pass in the Drip Coffee Brewing Process, revised 12 September 2016, Figures 1–3. Before you plot anything, identify what each part of the chart represents:

  • Horizontal axis: extraction (solubles yield), running from 14% to 26%.
  • Vertical axis: strength (solubles concentration), running from 0.80% to 1.60%.
  • Diagonal formula lines: grams of coffee per liter of input water, labeled from 40 to 70 g/L.
  • The region labeled Optimum Balance: a designation on the chart, not a guarantee that every coffee will taste best there.

The document's worked example uses 100 g of coffee to 2 L of water, or 50 g/L. Measured strength of 1.20% on that formula line plots at 21.5% extraction. The chart's extraction value comes from its own input-water convention. Simply multiplying 2,000 g of input water by 1.20% and dividing by 100 g would give 24%, not 21.5%. Neither number equals a beverage-based EY calculated from the measured weight of what you collected.

To use the chart: find your input ratio's formula line, then move along it to your measured strength, and read the extraction value below that point. Record the chart's issuer, its version and which convention produced the point. You can also plot your own beverage-based EY against strength. If you do, label that point separately so the two kinds of extraction figures never get mixed in your notes.

When the brew is diluted with bypass water

The 2016 guidelines were written for drip brewers that add bypass water, which is hot water routed around the coffee bed and blended in afterward. The concentrate coming off the bed is stronger than the finished, diluted coffee. The document therefore recalculates the formula lines for bypass setups. Always note which liquid you sampled, concentrate or finished blend, and how much bypass water was added. A concentrate reading plotted as though it were the finished cup will land in the wrong place.

A brew journal layout that keeps the numbers honest

An original worksheet layout for home brewing records. Each column holds one kind of information:

FieldWhat to write
MethodBrewer and technique
Dry doseGrams of coffee
Input waterGrams of water poured
Collected beverageGrams of liquid you ended up with
Bypass amountGrams added after brewing, if any
Sampling stageConcentrate or finished drink
InstrumentRefractometer model, or none
Calibration baselineZeroing water and any subtracted baseline
Corrected TDS%Reading after baseline correction
EY conventionBeverage-based, or chart/input-water based
Chart issuer and versione.g. SCAA, revised 12 September 2016
Plotted coordinatesStrength and extraction as plotted
Tasting notesYour sensory observations, kept separate

Never fill in an extraction number from taste alone. If a cup tastes thin or harsh, write that in the tasting column. Measured TDS, a calculated EY and the cup you actually tasted are only useful together when each is recorded as what it is.

Related articles